Now the euphoria of a G7 concluded under the admirable Basque sun has passed, it is clear that the world at the end of summer 2019 is facing an accumulation of tensions that are both geopolitical and economic, which make the task of the analyst particularly difficult and that of forecasters, even more so.
The markets did not disappoint those who made a triumph in gold this summer (over $1,500 per ounce) while the amount of debt at negative rates reached unsuspected levels (15,400 billion dollars!).
From the geopolitical point of view, there is of course always Iran and Venezuela as well as Brexit in Europe, but we must now add Hong Kong and then in Europe, Italy and Spain along with Germany in the final straightaway with Angela Merkel.
From the economic point of view, the trade conflict between China and the United States is still raging, but more so the fears of recession that are rising in both the United States and Europe, with a slow-down in most emerging countries, as in the example of India and China. Finally, the fires from the Amazon to Siberia have brought to the forefront the climatic and environmental emergencies still illustrated by one of the hottest summers in history.
Iran was the star of the G7 with the impromptu arrival in Biarritz of its foreign minister. After the mutual seizures of an Iranian tanker off Gibraltar and a British tanker offshore of Ormuz, we would like to believe in the slight relaxation on the Brent barrel barometer (already perceptible), which has returned to around $60 (CyclOpe’s forecast of last January).
Trade War, Cyclope Sees a Truce by the End of the Year
But to really bring Iran back to the negotiating table, would take a gesture on the part of the United States: for example, allowing Iranian oil buyers exemptions again, as was the case until last April. This would enable Iran to go from 200 to 300,000 bpd, which it exports today at a rate of one million bpd.
Is Donald Trump capable of this gesture of goodwill? Perhaps, but John Bolton, his evil genius, is opposed to it as are Israel and Saudi Arabia. For the moment, despite the endless and ongoing crisis in Venezuela and the instability that prevails in Libya, the oil market is in equilibrium, if not surplus, while the prices of natural gas and especially LNG have collapsed under the weight of global overcapacity.
Xi Jinping was not in Biarritz, but China was unavoidable. The Chinese president is facing three major problems: the confrontation with the United States, the slowdown in growth and Hong Kong. It is likely that Deng Hsiao Ping, who ordered the suppression of Tien An Men, would not be engaged in a standoff with the Hong Kong Democratic forces. While the extradition bill to China has certainly been withdrawn, it is apparent the authorities are playing upon the deterioration of the situation, and with the rise of violence, Xi cannot lose face, but he cannot do in Hong Kong what has been common in Tibet or Si Kiang with the Uyghurs. Hong Kong, in any case, is weakening its hand against the United States while the economy alternates between good and bad figures, though it is still giving some signs of weakness.
During the summer, the escalation of tariffs has continued and at this little game, the United States are not necessarily winners to the extent that this will be reflected in the prices of many manufactured items that Americans buy en masse for Christmas and “Super-Friday”. Donald Trump has already lightened up a bit with regard to Huawei.
The Chinese are paradoxically more comfortable: they can do without US oil and US LNG and their need for soybeans decreases with the spread of African swine fever, while Europe and Brazil can meet their needs for meat. That being said, negotiations are continuing and we continue to believe that by the end of the year a compromise will lead to a kind of peace of the braves.
The front line could then be in and around Europe. It is true the GAFA and French wine threat was carefully defused in Biarritz. But will these good words be enough? We are waiting of course for the “casting” of the future Commission and then the outcome of Brexit. Donald Trump has promised Boris Johnson a “historic” trade deal, but will he still be there to enjoy it? Nothing is less certain as the British situation is complicated in an institutional framework that even the British struggle to understand: the Queen sends the Parliament home for five weeks at the request of the Prime Minister and Parliament rebels.
Brexit Will Weaken an Already Fragile Europe
Elections are being prepared with the prospect of a Labour platform, next to which the collective programme of the French left of 1981 pales. The prospect of a “no deal” seems to be strengthening, but, whatever the outcome of the coming weeks, it is clear that it will weaken Europe at a moment when its main economic engine – Germany – is down and where political uncertainties are hovering over Italy and Spain. Europe will have a hard time this winter escaping economic stagnation, if not worse.
Will it be the same for the United States? This is one of the major issues of this season. The United States is now in the longest period of economic growth in its history. Admittedly, this growth is no longer very strong (2% or so), but it is enough to maintain a positive balance of job creation. On the other hand, it is clear that deep industrial America, from Indiana to Pennsylvania, continues to suffer. The Fed has listened to Donald Trump – a little – agreeing to lower its rates while the notion of excessive budget deficit is foreign to the Trumpian spirit.
Taking into account the fact that the United States will return to an election year (an election that Donald Trump is currently likely to win), that US oil and gas production continues to increase and that the new economy (that of the GAFA and beyond) does not seem to be running out of steam, the ugly word recession still seems excessive and the United States should continue on a growth rate probably a little less than 2% with a lot of dust under the carpet, but for later!
What is certain, however, is that most emerging countries are no longer so. It is difficult, of course, to measure the reality of the slowdown in Chinese growth. Official figures (6.2%) remain within the party’s range. Imports of raw materials (energy and metals) have not declined, but there is a virtual embargo on secondary materials that has disrupted flows of virgin materials.
In July, in any case, the growth of Chinese industrial production fell below 5%. The level of 5% is precisely that at which Indian growth fell while Narendra Modi turned to the most obtuse national-populism by annexing Kashmir. As for Latin America, its main locomotives, Brazil and Argentina, are at the heart of both economic and political crises.
“This Mountain of Debt Is Worrisome”
The general mood does not lend itself to optimism and we understand the disposition of the financial markets with investors who favour security at all costs, even if they accept negative returns. In the past, it was thanks to inflation that real interest rates could be negative and ruin rentiers within a few years. There is hardly any more inflation today, but it is current rates that are negative, including for less prestigious signatures like that of France.
In the short term, it is a lifeline for all impecunious states, but in the medium term this mountain of debt can legitimately cause worry. Finally, on the monetary side, the dollar appears more than ever a safe haven and it has steadily appreciated against the pound sterling, the euro and the yuan.
In this context, the commodity markets have been bleak, including those for which the fundamentals seemed rather favourable. This is the case for non-ferrous metals (with the exception of nickel) whose balance sheets for prices – like copper and tin – have continued to weaken.
During the summer, the most dramatic turnaround was iron ore, which virtually eliminated the entire rise in the aftermath of Vale’s accident in Brazil. At the same time, we must also mention the drop in “electric” metals such as cobalt and lithium.
On the energy side, the most pronounced decline was that of natural gas in Asia (LNG), but also in Europe. Oil could have gone the same way if Saudi Arabia had not reduced production to keep prices above $60 per barrel of Brent, despite a turbulent summer in the Gulf.
Lastly, gloom also reigns over the agricultural markets following excellent harvests of grains, sugar and coffee. As Europe prepares to negotiate a new, greener CAP than ever before, the United States is opening the floodgates of public aid (“a giant package”, tweeted Donald Trump) and India is subsidizing its sugar exports.
From this summer of 2019, only gold really stands out (and to a lesser extent silver) and nickel: gold, over $1,500 per ounce, is benefitting from negative rates and the appetite of central banks, while nickel is on the rise as a result of the Indonesian government’s decision to ban export of ore by the end of the year.
This is a marked return to uncertainty of which, as usual, commodity markets are the best indicator.
By Philippe Chalmin
To subscribe to the Monthly Report or Cyclope events please contact us at email@example.com
he oil market has just experienced an episode of rare violence, but it was only a flash in the pan. The 14 September attack rocked the markets and the price hike in the ensuing hours was the strongest since 1991 with Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait. On paper, half of the Saudi potential (5% of world production) was concerned, which swept away the surpluses that had hitherto weighed on the market. And then, the fragility of Saudi Arabia surprised most observers. Quickly however, the damage was repaired, or at least compensated and the logic of fundamentals has taken over. The barrel has dropped to a little over $60 for Brent and although there is now very little chance for Iranian oil to come back into the market in the near future, we are again in excess and around All Soul’s Day, the United States should become a net exporter of oil and liquid fuel: a first since the 1970s. There is no guarantee that OPEC will be able to provide the adjustment needed to keep prices even around the $60 mark. Let us add that the natural gas market, whether in the United States or in Asia for LNG, is also strongly bearish.
The other major preoccupation during this back-to-school season is the stalemate of the trade conflict between the United States and China: some gestures of good will (Chinese purchases of American soy, American flexibility vis-à-vis Huawei) alternate with new threats like that of the United States closing the US stock markets to Chinese companies. Negotiations will resume mid-October and we continue to think that a kind of ‘peace of the braves’ could come before the end of the year: the Chinese want it and are ready to make an effort and then Donald Trump finds something new to toy with.
The problem is that this is perfectly legal, since starting 18 October, the United States will be able to apply taxes to the tune of $7 billion on European products. The WTO, which the United States threatens to paralyze by refusing any confirmation of judges to the DSB, has condemned several European countries on the old Airbus file that dates back to 2004. Europe will probably be less tough than China and the list of products concerned will remind the oldest of a fairly similar list that was published twenty years ago when a WTO panel condemned the EU against the United States on the issue of hormone-treated beef. The presence of Roquefort in this list provoked the action of José Bové and the destruction of a McDonalds in Millau. Will it be the same this time with winemakers from Bordeaux and Burgundy? Next round at the WTO in a few months with a file on Boeing!
Like most energy markets, most commodities approached the fall looking rather bleak, with the exception of gold and palladium. From iron and scrap to sugar and coffee, on to derivative markets as well as to physical markets, price declines are more or less general. On the other hand, sea freight markets have rebounded dramatically: US sanctions against a Chinese tanker owner guilty of having loaded Iranian oil, bulk cargoes stuck off Iran and especially the revolution that will represent, on 1 January 2020, the adoption of the new standards of the IMO on marine fuels, are all elements that have influenced putting an end, for a time, to a long period of rather depressed freight.
Against the backdrop of a global economic slowdown, a decline in world trade and a strong dollar, market prospects remain poor.
Commodity Market Briefs
September 2019 – According to Stone consultants, Chinese pig meat imports are expected to double in two years from 2.1mt in 2018 to 3.3mt in 2019 and 4.2mt in 2020. Chinese production should rise by 54mt in 2018 to 34 mt in 2019. Chinese taxes on American pork will increase again on 1 September to 72%.
China’s demand for animal feed should fall by 37 mt, including 23 mt of corn and 10 mt of soya meal. Pork prices in China have increased by more than 25% between July and August and this rise could tarnish the celebrations of the seventieth anniversary of the People’s Republic, October 1st.
According to the ICSG, the global copper deficit in the first five months of 2019 increased by 45% to 190,000 tonnes. Primary production decreased by 1.3% to 8.07 mt. Secondary production increased by 1% to 1.7 mt and consumption decreased slightly by 0.3% to 9.9 mt. China’s apparent demand fell by 12%.
The IGC figures the world cereal crop in 2019/2020 at a record level of 2,159 mt and world trade at 370 mt.
India has granted subsidies of $876 million to help export 6 mt of sugar for the 2019/2020 season. The subsidy will be $146 per tonne. Australia, Brazil and Guatemala have called for the establishment of a WTO panel under the DSB.
Indonesia decided to advance its ban on nickel ore exports at the end of December, affecting 9% of the world’s mining output. That said, Indonesia will increase its nickel smelting (NPI) production from 261,000 tonnes in 2018 to potentially 530,000 tonnes in 2020. Goldman Sachs is forecasting a $20,000 per tonne target for the end of the year.
Of the top seven “sights” in 2019 up to August, De Beers’ gross diamond sales declined 26% to $2.9 billion. The market is in overproduction and is suffering from competition from new synthetic diamonds.
With the drop in cobalt prices, Glencore has closed its Mutanda mine in the DRC, the largest in the world.
In a gesture of “goodwill”, Saudi Arabia has decided to limit its restrictions on the import of wheat from Russia, which until now could not penetrate the Saudi market because of a level of contamination that was considered too high.
Indonesia may ban the export of nickel ore as of 2022. This has caused a surge in nickel prices, in excess of $16,000 per tonne on the LME and $17,000 in Shanghai.
In the first half of 2019, Chinese imports of refined copper decreased by 16%. On the other hand, imports of copper concentrates increased by 10% and those of waste decreased by 25%. For refined nickel, the decline is 18% while imports of nickel ore increased by 14%. To this should be added a doubling of imports of “ferro-nickel” from Indonesia (actually nickel smelting).
For 2019/2020, the ICAC anticipates a global cotton surplus of 500,000 tonnes. China will remain the world’s largest producer (5.9 mt) ahead of India (5.75 mt). The CFA zone should break a historic record at 1.3 mt.
Commodity Markets, Gold in High Demand
Global gold demand increased by 8% in the first half thanks to central bank purchases and ETFs. Demand was 2182 tonnes, of which 374 tonnes were for central banks and 107 tonnes for ETFs. The “production” of gold (mine and recycling) was 2,324 tonnes.
World steel production increased by 4.6% in the first half of the year to 925 million, mainly due to Asia, particularly China.
According to a Reuters poll, the average price of copper in the fourth quarter will be $3,291 per tonne (with a deficit of 178,000 tonnes), the nickel price of $12,738 (with a deficit of 19,500 tonnes), the aluminium of $1,850 (deficit of 550,000 tonnes) and zinc of $2,645 (deficit of 75,000 tonnes).
Chinese imports of “commodities” remain one of China’s major cards in its conflict with the United States: in a normal year, China imports $20 billion in agricultural products, $7.5 billion in oil (at current prices for 350,000 bd US oil), $1 billion of LNG and $1 billion of coal, and therefore a total of around $30 billion.
China’s leading construction company, CCCC, is negotiating a contract to dredge the Parana River in Argentina. 80% of Argentine grains pass through the Parana. The Chinese project would allow larger ships to go up river as far as Rosario.
There has been a sharp drop in China’s gold imports in the first half of the year: 575 tonnes in 2019, compared with 883 tonnes in 2018. The noticeable decrease in May and June (57 tonnes in June against 199 tonnes in June 2018) is linked to restrictions on import quotas imposed by the People’s Bank of China. These quotas were lifted in August, but an “import gap” of 300 to 500 tonnes is estimated.
While the Ghanaian authorities have decided to increase the price of cocoa to the planter by 5.2% for the next season, the EIU forecast for 2019 is $2,323 per tonne in 2019 and $2,248 in 2020; the floor price announced by Côte d’Ivoire and Ghana was set at $2,500. Then the two countries decided on a premium of $400 per tonne on the futures market price starting from the 2020/2021 season.
Is it a precursor to a crisis? The tin market is at its lowest in three years at less than $10,000 per tonne. The main reason is the declining demand from the semiconductor industry, which is suffering from the climate of the trade war. Tin used in electronic solders represents 47% of uses (14% for tinplate). Semiconductor sales fell 14.5% in the first half of the year.
Also in decline is the price of iron ore. After its peak of $122.20 on 3 July, the tonne sold in China had fallen at the end of August to $83, returning to levels comparable to those preceding the Brazilian disaster ($75 in January). The reason is less related to fundamentals than to the market’s “feeling” about possible recessions.
62% increase in Chinese pork imports to 160,000 tonnes. For the first semester, imports amounted to 818,000 tonnes (+26%). At 24.7 mt, Chinese production is down only 5%.
In the second quarter of 2019, Vale’s iron ore production in Brazil decreased by 34% to 64 mt.
The amount of aid given to the agricultural world by the US government will be $16 per acre ($40 per hectare), according to the Secretary of Agriculture. The overall package will be $16 billion following $12 billion in 2018.
At the end of July 2019, a survey conducted by Reuters with analysts and traders gave a year-end sugar price forecast of 13.80 cents/lb with a 2019/2020 global deficit of 2.95 mt on the basis of India’s production decline, going from 33 to 28.5 mt.
According to Alcoa, the global aluminium deficit will only be 1 to 1.4 mt in 2019.
The United States no longer dominates the global maize market: over 2018/2019, exports will hardly exceed 53 Mt while Brazil, Argentina and Ukraine are expected to reach close to 100 Mt.
Sharp drop in tea prices. For the first time since 2014, at an auction in Mombasa (Kenya), they went below $2 per kg to $1.80. In 2018, the average price was $2.58 for an estimated production cost of $2. World production, estimated at 5.88 mt, exceeds consumption (5.61 mt).
With the fall in sugar prices, Brazilian producers are using futures less and less to set their prices. On the current season, only 58% of anticipated exports were covered on the New York contract. In 2018, 68% had been covered. In any case, in Brazil, the share of sugar in cane crushing is expected to fall to 34.7%.
The lead market was 65,000 tonnes in deficit in the first half of the year, according to the ILZSG. That of zinc was in deficit by 134,000 tonnes, which did not prevent the continuation of the fall in prices.
The Australian wheat harvest may fall below 19 mt due to persistent drought. Australia produced 35 mt in 2016/2017. This is beneficial to Black Sea dealers who are now seeking Asian markets. At equal quality, a tonne of Australian wheat delivered to Asian ports is at $250 against $225 for Russian or Ukrainian wheat.
In July, global steel production increased 1.7% to 156.7 mt. But China saw its production increase by 5% to 85.3 mt.
An already old figure (2017), but global cocaine production has probably exceeded 2,000 tonnes.
Oil, Growth Forecast Revised Downwards
Rosneft, which produces 40% of Russian oil, has decided that all its exports of petroleum products will now be billed in euros. Rosneft sells half of its production of refined products by auction. In addition, Rosneft became Venezuela’s largest buyer and distributor of oil with two-thirds of the deliveries in August.
Rosneft sells directly to India and China while traders like Trafigura and Vitol have pulled out of this market for fear of US sanctions. These transactions are managed by Rosneft-Geneva.
China’s coal consumption is expected to peak in 2025, according to an official Chinese study (CNPC). By 2035, coal would represent only 40.5% of the energy consumed compared to 58% in 2018 (and 68.5% in 2012).
The IEA has revised downwards its growth forecast for world oil demand to 1.1 mbd in 2019, in particular because of China; from January to May, world demand rose by only 520,000 bd, the lowest since 2008. In August, OPEC released the same figure (1.1 mbd).
Oil geography is sometimes confusing: with its fast-growing refining capacity, China now exports gasoline to Mexico and Nigeria.
In June, the United States exported a record of 3.16 mbd of oil, mainly through purchases from South Korea. That same month, OPEC production was at its lowest for eight months at 29.42 mbd. In July, Saudi Arabia pumped only 9.65 mbd while its quota is 10.31 mbd.
There has been a discovery of an oil field in the delta of the Congo Basin by two Congolese companies controlled by a close associate of President Sassou Nguesso. He developed his experience by trading in Geneva and made a fortune by controlling the Congolese market of refined products.
By July, Iran’s oil exports dropped to 100,000 bd. Iran’s maximum export capacity is estimated at between 225,000 and 350,000 bd. Iran has 56 million barrels in floating storage and at least as much in the long term. On the other hand, Iran continues to export oil products and petroleum gas (LPG) at 400,000 bd, or $500 million a month.
In September, according to the EIA, shale oil production in the United States is expected to break a new record at 8.77 mbd of crude oil including 4.42 mbd for Permian and 1.44 mbd for Bakken.
There was a slight rise mid-August for LNG prices to $5 MBT in Asia (a year ago, it was $11). This being the case, this concerns the spot market and the bulk of the market remains on the basis of contracts. In the first seven months of the year, South Korea’s average import price was $10.22, and in June, Japan paid $9.14. Most of these contracts are indexed to the price of oil.
Kenya has exported oil for the first time (250,000 barrels) bought by trader Chem-China UK.
As of September 1, China has imposed a 5% tax on US oil. however, some importers like Sinopec have requested exemptions (waivers).
Morgan-Stanley has just reduced its forecast for the average price of a Brent oil barrel to $60 for 2019 (i.e. the CyclOpe forecast made… in January 2019!). A poll conducted by Reuters with 51 analysts gives an average price of $65 in 2019, down $2.50 from July.
In August, OPEC produced 29.61 mbd of oil, up 80,000 bd in July from Iraq and Nigeria. Russia, for its part, produced 11.29 mbd, the highest since March and beyond the commitments that would have been made in July (11.17 mbd).
To subscribe to the Monthly Report or Cyclope events please contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org